Certainly, if you’re trying to improve your AI-computing capabilities, getting people excited about edge cases is a good way to recruit smart people to your cause. And, if the problems Tesla has had
hitting its own goals is any indication, the company could use all the help it can get.
For example, Tesla is facing an investigation
into its autopilot feature over a series of incidents where the company’s vehicles collided with emergency vehicles with their lights flashing along the side of the road. Will a Tesla Bot randomly run into your couch, or table?
Musk also promised there would be a million fully autonomous vehicles on the road
by the middle of 2020. That still hasn’t happened. Eventually, all of those broken promises add up and start to damage your credibility. That’s a problem for obvious reasons. Finding smart people to help Tesla solve the challenges of AI is a smart move–especially if it means that it can actually deliver on those promises.
There is another problem, however. The fact that Musk had to clarify that you’ll be able to outrun the bot, and that you should have no trouble overpowering it, says a lot about the level of anxiety most people have about inviting an artificially intelligent computer, shaped like a human, into their home. As cool as it might sound, I’m not sure the world is ready for that.
I’m also skeptical that–assuming Tesla ever delivers this product–it will lead to the AI-driven utopia that Musk is promising. Musk seems to think that having a robot that can handle trivial labor will lead to a future where “physical work will be a choice.” Of course, in this version, everyone would be supported by a universal basic income from the government. There are a lot of dots to connect there, and almost none of them seem likely any time soon.
What does seem likely would be that instead of a robot that can take care of mundane tasks like grocery shopping, corporations and ultra-wealthy individuals would simply buy them all to replace workers on assembly lines, in grocery stores, or at restaurants, putting millions of people out of work. That’s not exactly utopia.
That’s why I have a hard time deciding whether the entire thing is terrifying, or brilliant. I suppose it’s both. For Tesla, it’s brilliant if your goal is to attract attention and the talent you need to make it happen.
For the rest of us, I’m comforted by the fact that the chances of seeing one of these walking down the aisle in the grocery store towards me are practically zero. That’s a good thing because the thought of that is absolutely terrifying.